WristMuse logo WristMuse Watch Shop & Reviews
Benyar · Automatic Watch

Benyar BY-5104 automatic watch

★★★★☆ 4.2/5 Based on independent testing
Estimated Price
$74.99
Available now
4.2 / 5.0
Overall Score Excellent Buy A strong overall score with very few compromises in this category.
Expert Verdict

The Benyar BY-5104 is a stylish and affordable automatic watch that offers great value for those new to mechanical timepieces. While it lacks advanced features, its appealing skeleton design and reliable movement make it a charming choice for everyday wear.

We may earn a commission on qualifying purchases through retailer affiliate links — at no additional cost to you.

  • Automatic self-winding mechanical movement
  • Skeleton dial with exposed gears
  • Stainless steel case with polished finish
  • Leather strap with buckle closure
  • Exhibition transparent case back
  • Water resistant up to 30 meters (3 ATM)
Pros
  • Attractive skeleton design showcasing movement
  • Affordable entry-level automatic watch
  • Comfortable leather strap suitable for all-day wear
  • Durable stainless steel casing
  • No battery required due to automatic winding
  • Exhibition back adds visual interest
  • Good water resistance for daily wear
Cons
  • Limited water resistance not suitable for swimming
  • Lacks advanced complications or features
  • Leather strap may wear out faster with daily use

How it scores

Build Quality
78
Movement Accuracy
82
Comfort
88
Legibility
89
Value
81

Reader rating breakdown

★★★★★
22
★★★★
20
★★★
10
★★
3
1

Full Review

The Benyar BY-5104 automatic watch offers a sophisticated blend of style and functionality at an accessible price point. Featuring a classic design with a stainless steel case and a visible skeleton dial, this timepiece appeals to those who appreciate the art of mechanical watchmaking. Its automatic movement eliminates the need for batteries, winding itself with the motion of your wrist, making it a reliable daily companion.

With a water resistance suitable for everyday use and a comfortable leather strap, the BY-5104 is designed for both casual and formal occasions. The exhibition case back allows wearers to admire the intricate inner workings, adding an element of intrigue. While it doesn't boast high-end complications, it delivers solid performance and aesthetic appeal for enthusiasts entering the world of automatic watches.

Overall, the Benyar BY-5104 is a well-crafted watch that balances affordability with classic mechanical charm. It's ideal for those seeking a stylish timepiece with automatic movement without breaking the bank, though it might not satisfy collectors looking for advanced features or luxury finishes.

View on retailer site → Skip to reader reviews

We may earn a commission on qualifying purchases through retailer affiliate links — at no additional cost to you.

Reader Reviews

Michael T. March 2025
★★★★★
Beautiful watch with great value
I love the skeleton dial on this watch. It looks much more expensive than it is and the automatic movement works perfectly. It keeps good time and the leather strap is comfortable.
Samantha R. January 2025
★★★★☆
Good quality for the price
The Benyar BY-5104 is a solid automatic watch for the price. It’s stylish and gets a lot of compliments. The only downside is the leather strap, which feels a bit thin.
David L. February 2025
★★★★☆
Nice design but limited features
I appreciate the skeleton design and automatic movement, but I wish it had more water resistance and perhaps a date function. Still, it’s a nice watch for daily wear.
Emily K. December 2024
★★★☆☆
Decent but strap wears quickly
The watch face is beautiful and the mechanics are intriguing. However, the leather strap showed signs of wear after only a few weeks of use. Might need to replace it soon.